Appetizers 

Sauerkraut Balls (4) hand-rolled balls filled with a secret blend of spices & pork roasted with savory kraut, served with cocktail sauce & house mustard  _8 ⁹⁵

Deviled Eggs^GF local egg, sky haven ham, pickled red onion   _8 ⁹⁵

Golden Lamb Farms Platter pickled peaches, house recipe egg salad, pickled cauliflower & pearl onions, shaved Sky Haven ham, house-made garlic crackers _16 ⁹⁵

Chilled Shrimp Dijonaise^GF (4) domestic gulf shrimp, house-made dijonnaise & pickled mustard seeds _16 ⁹⁵

Hickory Smoked Chicken Wings^GF (3) colossal whole dry-rubbed wings, Chef’s creamy dip, house hot sauce, fresh celery ribs _12 ⁹⁵

Basket of Cheese Curds tangy ranch dip _8 ⁹⁵

Cheese & Crackers Cotswold, Danish Bleu cheese, whipped Capriole Chevre, fresh fruit, peppadews, candied pecans, local honeycomb & house-made garlic crackers _14 ⁹⁵

Saratoga Nachos sea salt chips, white cheddar sauce, barbecue sauce, pickled peppers, Danish Bleu cheese & chives _10 ⁹⁵

Creamy Smoked Salmon Dip cream cheese, capers, lemon, dill & house-made garlic crackers _14 ⁹⁵

Salads & Soups

Enhance Your Salad
Sliced Tenderloin* _12 ⁹⁵     Seared Salmon* _10 ⁹⁵     Bronzed Chicken Breast _8 ⁹⁵      Chilled Shrimp* _9 ⁹⁵ 

Signature House^GF field greens, house-made creamy balsamic dressing, smoked cheddar, candied pecans, green apple _10 ⁹⁵

Baby Kale & Marinated Tomato Salad baby kale, roasted garlic dressing, balsamic marinated cherry tomatoes, grated parmesan, house-made garlic cracker croutons _11 ⁹⁵

Midwestern Chopped Salad iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, shaved red onions, local egg, chopped bacon, crispy onions, Tillamook cheddar cheese, Chef's creamy herb dressing _11 ⁹⁵

SOUP: half-bowl _4 ⁹⁵  bowl _7 ⁹⁵      

Creamy Tomato Bisque^GF with goat cheese & basil oil

Shaker Chicken & Spaetzle with fresh herbs 

Main Courses

Enjoy a signature salad for _3 ⁹⁵ with your historic dining selection

Split entrees are available for _6 ⁹⁹  & served with a full complement of side items

Golden Lamb Roast Turkey Dinner brined and slow-roasted turkey breast, sage sausage & apple dressing, seasonal vegetables, cranberry chutney, mashed potatoes with two-day turkey gravy _25 ⁹⁵

Shepherd's Pie^GF Pennsylvania raised lamb, local mushrooms, garlic, edamame, green beans, sun-dried tomatoes, caramelized onions, lamb stock reduction, baked with goat cheese & herb potatoes _25 ⁹⁵

Braised Lamb Shank^GF creamy parmesan polenta, roasted broccoli, red wine reduction demi-glace, gremolata _35 ⁹⁵

Dijon Crusted Braised Short Rib clapshot potatoes, roasted broccoli, rosemary jus _29 ⁹⁵

Chateaubriand^GF crushed roasted leek & bacon red skin potatoes, white cheddar cheese sauce, maple glazed brussels sprouts _42 ⁹⁵

Pan Seared Halibut^GF smoked carrot puree, garlic parmesan ancient grains, roasted broccoli, paprika infused local honey, basil pesto _32 ⁹⁵

Ohio Fried Chicken Dinner skillet gravy, mashed potatoes, fresh seasonal vegetables

Original 1/2 Chicken _24 ⁹⁵
1/4 White - Breast & Wing _19 ⁹⁵
1/4 Dark - Leg & Thigh _17 ⁹⁵

Seared Faroe Island Salmon* herbed couscous & sautéed red pepper, maple glazed brussels sprouts, sundried tomato & roasted red pepper cream sauce _30 ⁹⁵

Couscous, Mushroom & Vegetable "Cobbler" pearl couscous, local mushrooms, roasted garlic, edamame, green beans, sun dried tomato, spinach, goat cheese cream, buttery biscuit crumble _24 ⁹⁵

Roasted Butternut Squash Lasagna house-made ricotta, parmesan, herbed Mornay sauce, butternut squash, sautéed kale, candied pecans, balsamic reduction _24 ⁹⁵

Winter Vegetable & Grain Bowl sautéed butternut squash & kale, roasted broccoli, sun dried tomatoes, bell peppers, garbanzo beans, couscous, sage pesto, lemon dill sauce, smoked pepitas _24 ⁹⁵

Weekly Specials

Sundays & Mondays starting at 4 p.m.

Prime Rib Dinner Special mixed carrots & green beans with mashed potatoes & gravy _46⁹⁵

Burgers & Sandwiches

served with tavern fries unless otherwise stated

mixed greens with creamy balsamic or broccoli slaw available upon request

Sonny Marie's Gluten-Free Bun on any sandwich _1 ⁹⁹

Grilled Lamb Burger* toasted fennel seasoned Pennsylvania lamb, caramelized onions, creamy herb cheese & tomato chutney _17 ⁹⁵

Original Sticky Burger* house-made peanut butter, bacon, bbq, sharp cheddar, garlic aioli & crispy onions _17 ⁹⁵

Tavern Cheeseburger* Tillamook cheddar, garlic aioli, crisp lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle _16 ⁹⁵

Braised Short Rib Grilled Cheese pimento cheese, caramelized onions, pickled jalapenos, toasted sour dough _18 ⁹⁵

Sliced Tenderloin Sandwich shaved chateaubriand, white cheddar, crispy onion straws, garlic aioli, toasted onion bun _22 ⁹⁵

Fried Chicken Club Sandwich Golden Lamb fried chicken breast, Sky Haven ham, Tillamook cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, cajun mayo, toasted wheat bread _16 ⁹⁵

1803 Chicken Salad Sandwich chicken breast, red grapes, pecans, celery, onion, mixed with creamy dressing, toasted croissant, served with sea salt chips _14 ⁹⁵

Turkey Reuben Golden Lamb roasted turkey, caramelized green apples, sauerkraut, Russian dressing, Swiss cheese, butter-toasted rye bread _16 ⁹⁵

Roasted Squash Sando roasted butternut squash, spring mix, candied pecans, Fresno pepper & apple chutney, house whipped ricotta, balsamic drizzle, toasted wheat bread _16 ⁹⁵

We take pride in being an all-scratch kitchen, and our Chefs will gladly craft a special meal for guests with food allergies or dietary needs.

Many of our ingredients are regionally sourced throughout the year starting with our own Golden Lamb Farm established in 2018.

*GF denotes menu items without gluten in the recipe

*We are required to inform you that consuming raw or undercooked ingredients may increase your risk for foodborne illness